The New Lost Boys quest walkthrough in Disney Dreamlight Valley – Destructoid

Peter Pan’s friendship quests continue in Disney Dreamlight Valley, with his level seven mission, “The New Lost Boys,” focusing on finding new friends. He decides that he needs some desserts and asks you for help in baking while he gathers up a few villagers for a special surprise.

Cook pies for Peter Pan’s surprise

After starting Peter Pan’s level seven friendship quest, he’ll ask you to cook up the following desserts:

He’ll give you recipe books for all three, making it easier to learn what ingredients you need for each. Here’s a breakdown of the total items you’ll need for all nine pies:

• Apple (3)
• Dreamlight Fruit (3)
• Lemon (3)
• Egg (3)
• Wheat (9)
• Butter (9)
• Coal (9)

All three pie recipes involve wheat and butter for their crusts, while each type needs apples, lemons, and Dreamlight Fruit for their fillings. Meringue pie differs slightly, with eggs also required for the meringue layer. The last requirement is coal for fueling your stovetop’s flames while cooking.

Once you have all the ingredients, use your cooking menu’s search function to filter by quest, allowing you to bake each pie before giving them to Peter Pan.

Checking in on your villagers

After giving Peter Pan the pies, he’ll tell you that the Fairy Godmother needs your help. Since we’re the protagonist of this story, you’ll run to the Fairy Godmother’s aid without hesitation. However, there’s a twist: she’s completely fine.

It turns out Peter Pan tricked you into leaving him alone so he could prank some villagers with the pies. You’ll need to visit Donald Duck, Merlin, and Scar to clean up the messes Peter left. Make sure you get every pie pile to advance the quest. They’re all within each house, so you won’t have to worry about searching any biomes.

Scar’s Lair bug

There’s also a possibility you’ll encounter a bug during the Scar’s Lair portion of this quest. The mission’s objective will update a few times, even if you clear all the pie filling. Your best bet for avoiding this is to stay inside the house to let Peter Pan and Scar speak to each other before talking to Peter as your next objective. Leaving the cave can trigger this bug, making it impossible to progress through the quest.

If you’ve found this bug and have no way to advance it, you can use the tips below to try to resolve it:

• Leave and reenter Scar’s Lair only if you know the quest isn’t updating as it should.
• If you’re hanging out with any villagers, tell them to stop.
• Close and reopen Disney Dreamlight Valley.
• Uninstall and reinstall Disney Dreamlight Valley.

If the tips above don’t work, you can also contact Gameloft’s support page or wait for an official update about this bug.

Craft Lost Boys audition signs

Once you finish your conversation with Peter Pan and resolve any potential quest bugs, it’s time to make some Lost Boys audition signs. Here’s a list of every item you need:

• Softwood (50)
• Dry Wood (25)
• Green Passion Lily (10)
• Red Passion Lily (10)

The trickiest part is obtaining each Passion Lily, especially if you’re not someone who collects and stores them for gifting or future quests. You can find both in Frosted Heights, which is also where you can grab extra Dry Wood. If you don’t see all the flowers you need, leave the area and recheck it after about 20 to 30 minutes to find more spawns. You may have to sidetrack to another quest, depending on how many more you need.

Once you have each item, head to any crafting table, navigate to Furniture, and craft the Lost Boys audition signs. You’ll now need to place all five anywhere around your Dreamlight Valley village. Where you arrange them is entirely up to you.

What follows is an adorable sequence of events involving Peter Pan meeting some new potential Lost Boys. There’s no right or wrong answer in any of these dialogue options, so choose whichever one fits your personality and preferences. These series of conversations will conclude the “The New Lost Boys” quest and prepare you for Peter Pan’s final friendship mission once you reach level 10 with him.